◆ ENT 1000 · Foundations of Entrepreneurship and Design · Mon Nov 9, 2026 · Week 10, Day 1

Break it on purpose.

Jay Margalus · jaymargalus.com/foundations · a bench test, July 2017

Today · 2:45–4:15
2:45News10 min
2:55Two teams present, five to seven minutes each15 min
3:10Break it on purpose: test cards, learning cards, and the real thing30 min
3:40Group time: ten real ones, then the ones that trip it up30 min
4:10Coming up, and Log 105 min
3:10 · 3 min · what I read in Log 9 · 20 of 20 in
"We've tested the full workflow using fictional recruiting data, but still need to validate it with real coaches."
"So far, we have used made up examples to see how everything works."
"We have now tested the app through various sample invoices, and the app ran all of them and gave an actual output that could potentially be useful."
"All three steps work end to end on sample data (self-test 25/25), but none run on real inputs yet."

Four teams, four logs, one sentence. Most of the room wrote some version of it.

3:13 · 2 min

It works on the examples you made up.
Nine days from now your contact hands it the real thing.

Nov 16–20 your assistant runs at your partner business. You won't be in the room.

3:15 · 3 min · from Week 6 of the capstone, 2023 · same slide, same rule

Confidence level: two things decide it.

Type and strength of evidence

  • Interviews, surveys: low confidence. What people say and what they do are often two different things.
  • Simulated sales, a user test: high confidence.
  • The email you typed to test it: "John Smith, QB, 3.8 GPA, class of 2028." The email Coach G. actually got last Tuesday: a highlight-reel link, no GPA, and a question about visiting campus.

Number of data points

  • 10 people? Low. 500? Higher.
  • One team ran two emails through their assistant this week. Both came out right. 2 of 2 says nothing. Another team ran one real insurance card, and it broke a rule the fakes never touched.
  • Run forty of the coach's real emails and you get a number like 31 of 40, plus a list of the nine it got wrong. In the video, "31 of 40 of the coach's real emails" beats "it works."

Forty is the number on the checklists page (the "Break it on purpose" option). That's where it comes from.

3:18 · 4 min · the test card · you've filled these out since Week 3

Write the guess before you run it.

We believe that

our assistant will pull the recruit's name, position, and GPA from any email a coach forwards.

To check that, we will

feed it ten real emails from Coach G.'s inbox from October.

And measure

how many of the ten come out with all three fields right, checked by hand.

We are right if

nine of ten.

  • One card per guess, not per input. "It works" is not a guess.
  • "We are right if" is a number you pick before you run it. Afterward you'll want to move it.
  • "To check that" names real ones from your contact. Ask for last month's pile, not for examples. People hand you the clean ones.
  • The things it should not do get a card too: "We believe it hands anything medical to a person. We are right if ten of ten."
3:22 · 3 min · the learning card · "one guess you checked" in every Log

What you write down when it fails.

We believed that

the assistant could read every field off an insurance card.

We observed

a real card with no group number printed on it. The assistant flagged the whole card as unreadable.

From that we learned

real cards don't always print a group number, policyholder, or date of birth. All our fake ones did.

Therefore we will

skip a missing field instead of rejecting the card. One of twenty real ones done.

  • That card is one of yours, from Log 8. One real input, one dead guess.
  • A learning card is the "one guess you checked" box in the Log. Same four lines.
  • A fail isn't a bad grade. It's the only kind of run that teaches you something.
  • The ones you decide not to fix get a card too, with "therefore we will leave it, because…"
3:25 · 5 min · when you can't get the real ones

Made-up examples that count.

Get the shape, not the contents

  • Ask your contact for one, blacked out. Names, numbers, dates crossed off. You want the length, the missing fields, the typos.
  • Ask for the three that would trip up a new hire. Write them down in your contact's words.
  • Have your contact grade ten of yours. "I get ones like that" or "nobody writes like that."

Make them hard on purpose

  • Another team writes five for you without seeing your rules. You know your edges and avoid them. They don't.
  • Copy a real mess: a photo of a paper form, a reply at the bottom of a long chain, a date written three ways.
  • Let the assistant make thirty variations of one blacked-out example. You still write "we are right if" by hand first.

In the Log, say which: real · blacked-out real · made up and graded by your contact · made up by you. Only the last one is "none yet."

4:10 · 5 min

Coming up.

  1. Wed Nov 11. Read Minimalist ch. 6–7 before class. Shoot the video. Rough cuts.
  2. Fri Nov 13, 11:59pm. Log 10, Google Form. Required under Key decisions this week: how the business makes money. Also Book memo 2 on Canvas.
  3. Tue Nov 17, 11:59pm. Pitch video on Canvas, one per team, three minutes max.
  4. Thu Nov 19 · Video Pitch Competition. Required, and it counts as a class day. Judged by alumni from the Connolly Center board.
  5. Fri Nov 20, 11:59pm. Log 11. The judges' feedback goes here.
What goes in Log 10 · Fri Nov 13
FieldThis week
EvidenceWho you talked to, in their words. Asking your contact for the pile counts. Two a week through this week is the floor.
Key decisionsRequired this week: how the business makes money. Who pays, for what, how much, how often. "Name your price" from Week 5 is the start.
One guess checkedA test card and its learning card. Ran __, got __ right, the worst miss and what it told you.
Harness changeThe one thing you changed after the run, with the score before and after.
Touch-point statusWhich of the three steps run on what: real · blacked-out real · made up and graded by your contact · made up by you. The last one is "none yet." Say so; it's fine.
Working / notWhat broke that you didn't expect.
BookCh. 6–7, due Wednesday, tied to your project.
AI auditWhat you had it do, what you did, what you checked. The cards are the check.

Questions.

jaymargalus.com/foundations · jmargalus@wlu.edu · Holekamp 109 · Mon + Wed 1:45–2:30

A workbench covered in wires and parts
The bench, last Tuesday
4:00
ENT 1000 · Week 10 · Day 1