Same guy and the same game, with more than twice the money and twice the backers.
What changed
December 2012
March 2013
Video
8 min 09 sec
4 min 53 sec, same footage, 40% cut
Goal
$25,500
$15,000, "only the bare essentials"
The money is for
Sound effects $12k · music $4k · art $4k · PAX East $2k · website $1k
Art and music. That's it.
Playable demo
Arrived late in the campaign
On the page from day one
Month
December. Final week was Christmas.
March
Updates · comments
16 · 169
53 · 340
Result
$18,615 · 840 backers
$41,259 · 1,733 backers
He also emailed every one of the 840 who backed the first one. The second campaign hit its goal in days.
What he cut out of the video · 8:09 → 4:53
Gone
The lonely-night-with-the-GameCube origin story
Why sound effects cost twelve thousand dollars
PAX East, the website, and "why should you fund promotion?"
Reading the reward tiers out loud ("look over on your right")
"If by some luck we get more money than that..."
Kept
"Hey folks, I'm Craig Stern," then what the game is and how long he's been at it. Twenty seconds in.
The feature list, over gameplay
Why single-player needs more art and music
One ask and a thank-you.
Kickstarter's own guide: "When you think you're done, take a break, then come back and cut out 25% of the video. YOU MUST." He cut 40.
What he said he learned · "How to not fail at Kickstarter in 12 easy steps," April 2013
"You are not going to convince anyone to back your game simply by filming yourself talking at the camera; your game is going to have to sell itself."
"Keep the pitch video short. Between 1 and 2 minutes is good... If your pitch video is longer than 5 minutes, it's way too long."
"Explain why you need the money... Just saying 'that's where you come in' doesn't cut it these days."
"Set the lowest possible funding goal that will get the game made."
Also on his list: lead with footage of the thing, have a demo from day one, and don't run it in December. Your video is due Nov 17 and Thanksgiving is the week after, so plan around it.
3:17 · 12 min
Cards Against Humanity.
December 2010. Eight friends. A $4,000 ask. 1 min 51 sec.
Twenty-six seconds in, you've met all eight of them. "I'm Ben and I'm one of the creators." Couch, phone camera, done.
One line says what it is. "A party game for horrible people." Then they stop describing and play a round on camera.
The pitch makes the same joke the game makes. By the end you know exactly what you'd be buying.
The ask is plain. "Order the game and work with us to get these first copies made." The number is on the page: $4,000 for the first printing, $15 a deck.
It's 1:51. It ends on a blooper. "My hand was covering the microphone." They left it in.
A phone on a couch was enough. They told you who they are, played the game, and asked for $4,000. Kickstarter's guide, 2009: sound "is actually even more important than the image."
3:24 · 4 min · with your team
Your pitch in five lines.
Who we are, and who we built this for.
The job, in your contact's words.
What you built, doing the job on something real from the business.
What changed. The number before, the number after, and what your contact said.
The ask. One number and what it buys.
One line each, on one card. Two teams read theirs out loud. A blank line is your work for this week.
3:29 · 6 min · the beats
Kickstarter's list, and yours.
Kickstarter, 2011
Your video, due Tue Nov 17 · three minutes max
Introduce yourself
Every teammate on camera. Names, who your partner business is.
Tell your story
The problem, in your contact's words if you can get them.
Show the thing
The assistant running, on real information, on screen.
Ask, and explain why
The evidence: before numbers, what changed, what your contact said.
Say what they get
The other ten: who else would pay, and why.
Say thank you
What you're asking for. Then thank them.
Left column: Kickstarter's "Tips for Making Your Project Video," June 2011. Right column: the checklist on the deliverables page. They line up almost one to one.
Rules of thumb
Rule
Where it comes from
Who, what, and for whom in the first twenty seconds.
Kickstarter's video guide, 2009
Show the thing running instead of describing it.
Craig's step 3; the CAH video
One number in the ask, and what it buys.
Craig's step 6; CAH's $4,000
Cut 25% after you think you're done.
Kickstarter's guide. Craig cut 40.
Light and sound beat the camera. Daylight, a quiet room, the mic close.
Kickstarter's guide
Be yourself on camera. Nobody's grading production value.
Kickstarter, 2011; Lavingia, ch. 5
Three minutes max. Every teammate on camera. I'd aim for 2:30, but that's advice.
The checklist
3:35 · 25 min · teams
Storyboard your three minutes.
Six boxes on paper, thirty seconds each.
In every box: what's on screen · who's talking · the one line they say.
Box 1 is the first twenty seconds: who you are, the job, the person it's for.
Box 3 or 4 is the assistant running on a real input. Decide now what you'll record and when.
The last box is the ask, the number, and thank you.
Write who shoots what on the back. Photograph the board before you leave. You'll want it when you shoot.
4:05 · 6 min
Swap and cut.
Trade boards with the team next to you.
Mark the 25% you'd cut. Circle it.
Write the one beat that's missing in the margin.
Hand it back. Write down what they said instead of arguing with it.
Craig needed 840 strangers to tell him what to cut. You get a team and six minutes.
4:11 · 4 min
Coming up.
Wed Nov 4. Read Minimalist ch. 5 before class.
Fri Nov 6, 11:59pm. Log 9, Google Form. Same fields as always.
Wed Nov 11. Read Minimalist ch. 6–7 before class.
Fri Nov 13, 11:59pm. Log 10, and Book memo 2 on Canvas.
Tue Nov 17, 11:59pm. Pitch video on Canvas, one per team, three minutes max.
Thu Nov 19 · Video Pitch Competition. Required, and it counts as a class day. Judged by alumni from the Connolly Center board.